Design Book › Worked example: an open quadruped, Pupper and Doggo

Worked example: an open quadruped, Pupper and Doggo

Result. Two open quadrupeds have priced parts lists in this database, and they show two actuation choices. This site can show the prices of one of them.

The arithmetic is in tools/book_calcs/quadruped.py; its output is tools/book_calcs/out/quadruped.md. The Pupper part of that output uses the sheet's prices, which this site cannot show.

Pupper parts list

Source: the Stanford Pupper BOM sheet (pupper). The source record notes that no licence was found for the sheet. So this site shows none of its rows, and this chapter gives no Pupper cost. The parts the sheet names include JX CLS6336 hobby servos as joint actuators, a Raspberry Pi 4 for compute, and an optional IMU set (BNO080, Teensy LC). The sheet also prices printed parts and carbon fiber plates.

The pack trap

A catalog BOM row can hold a price for one thing and a quantity of another. On Pupper, many hardware rows hold a pack price against a piece count. The database moves those prices to price_note.

The pack rule: for an item in packs of N, buy ceil(total pieces over all its rows / N) packs. For example, if three rows ask for 40 screws in all and the screws come in packs of 100, buy one pack. A naive sum counts the pack price 40 times.

Rows that the sheet marks as repeats, and rows priced per length with a bare count, need a choice. State the choice next to the total.

The Doggo sheet avoids the trap. It names the pack in the item and counts packs, so quantity x price is the buy cost:

The pack trap
Doggo rowQtyPrice each (USD)Cost (USD)
M3x10 screws, 100 pack16.006.00
Threaded insert pack, 100 pack111.8911.89
Dowel Pin, 10 pack15.795.79
Outer Bearing, 2 pack48.9835.92

Doggo parts list and cost

Source: the Stanford Doggo BOM sheet (stanford-doggo), marked work in progress in the source record. 43 rows, all priced in USD, 19 linked.

Doggo parts list and cost
GroupRowsSum qty x price (USD)Share
Co-axial leg drive121,225.8841.3%
Electronics15889.7329.9%
Legs6411.4013.8%
Body5254.288.6%
3D printed components1163.305.5%
General hardware426.430.9%
Total432,971.02

Drive chain and custom parts, pulled out of those groups:

Doggo parts list and cost
LineQtyUnit USDUSD
T-Motor MN5212 KV340882.92663.36
ODrive 24V4119.00476.00
AS5047D encoder board815.75126.00
70T GT2/3 timing belt86.0048.00
Drive chain1,313.36 (44.2%)
Waterjet links1306.00306.00
Outer leg shaft1247.40247.40
All 3D printed parts1163.30163.30
CNC routed carbon fiber1120.00120.00
Waterjet sheet metal braces1105.30105.30
Custom-made942.00 (31.7%)

Drive chain per motor: 1,313.36 / 8 = $164.17.

The two designs side by side

The two designs side by side
ItemPupperDoggo
Joint actuatorJX CLS6336T-Motor MN5212 KV340, 8
Actuators per legnot shown2
Catalog classhobby servooutrunner BLDC, with a timing belt stage
Reductioninside the servo, per the class row; ratio not in database70T GT2/3 belts; ratio not in database
Driverinside the servo, per the class rowODrive 24V, one per two motors
Position sensorinside the servo, per the class rowAS5047D, 8
ControllerRaspberry Pi 4Teensy 3.5
Batterynot shown"Batteries", 2; no spec in database
Totalnot shown$2,971.02
Custom-made sharenot shown31.7%

What the guidelines and class rows say about each choice. None of it is a measurement of these two robots, except where it names Doggo.

The two designs side by side
TopicStatementSource
Low ratioQDD uses a single-stage reduction under 10:1. It raises torque at the expense of control bandwidth and keeps the motor backdrivable[1], from the Doggo paper
Motor scalingWith motor mass scaling with radius, torque scales with radius squared, reflected inertia with radius cubed[2]
Outrunner heatOutrunners trade thermal dissipation and inertia for torque density[3]
Low ratio and heatA low ratio can raise Joule heating for a given torque[4]
Doggo's motor testRaised current until the winding reached a steady 125 C[5]
Doggo's commutationField-oriented commutation at 10 kHz; an example, not a limit[6]
Hobby PWM servo classNo position, load or temperature feedback to the hostclass row act-hobby-pwm-servo
Outrunner classRated for airflow in flight, so continuous current in a sealed joint is lower; datasheets are often headline figures onlyclass row motor-outrunner-bldc

The class ranges below describe the outrunner family, not the MN5212. Do not read them as its values.

The two designs side by side
FamilyAttributenLowMedianHigh
Outrunner BLDCKV10265 rpm/V1,950 rpm/V27,000 rpm/V
Outrunner BLDCMass1101.7 g33.8 g1.74 kg
Outrunner BLDCPrice80$10.90$25.90$689.90

The ranges count only the values this site can show. It can show a stall torque and a mass for only one hobby PWM servo, so the table gives no range for that family.

The $82.92 Doggo motor row is above the median outrunner price and far below the top of the range. The median mass of 33.8 g and median KV of 1,950 rpm/V show that at least half the family are small, fast motors, so the median price says little about a leg motor. The Pupper part's catalog class is hobby-servo; the database does not record whether it takes PWM.

The check you cannot run yet

The rated-torque check needs a load and a rated torque [7]. The method is the same as the knee check in chapter 20. Here is what it needs and what the database holds.

The check you cannot run yet
InputPupperDoggo
Robot masspaper value, not shown; the control code models a 0.56 kg frame, four 0.08 kg leg modules and four 0.03 kg legspaper value, not shown
Leg link lengthsnot in databasenot in database
Actuator rated torquenot in databasenot in database
Actuator stall or peak torquenot in databasenot in database
Reduction rationot in databasenot in database
Bus voltagenot shown24 V in the driver's name only
Battery capacitynot shownnot in database
Upstream simulation modelnone in the librarynone in the library

The parts JX CLS6336, T-Motor MN5212 KV340, ODrive 24V and AS5047D have catalog rows and BOM prices, and no fact rows. Until those are collected, treat any torque claim about these robots as unchecked here.

Other open quadruped entries do not fill this gap either. ODRI Solo has URDF rows and no BOM rows. Pupper v3 is a separate catalog entry with a URDF row and no BOM rows. ODRI Actuator Module v1 has 34 unpriced rows around a T-Motor Antigravity 4004. Its fact rows claim 9:1 total reduction and 2.5 N·m at 12 A, but they describe that module, not Pupper or Doggo.

Safety rows

Doggo lists one relay under power distribution: "Solidstate Relay (Replaces minitactor)", $137.92. Pupper lists no switch, relay or fuse row. Neither list has a fuse or breaker row, so the fuse-or-breaker check is open for both [8]. These lists may not be complete; the database only shows what the rows say.

Guidelines this example exercises

Guidelines this example exercises
GuidelineResult here
A servo's stall torque is its maximum momentary output and differs from its continuous rating. Real-world output is generally closer to the performance-graph measurements [7]; In continuous operation keep motor torque below the thermally set continuous limit, not the peak or stall value. [9]Cannot run: no torque values.
Quasi-direct drive uses a single-stage reduction with a ratio under 10:1. It raises torque at the expense of control bandwidth but keeps the motor backdrivable [1]; Low gear ratios reduce reflected inertia but can increase Joule-heating energy for a given torque [4]; With motor mass scaling with radius, torque scales with radius squared and reflected inertia with radius cubed [2]; Expect outrunner motors to trade reduced thermal dissipation and higher inertia for higher torque density. [3]Explain the Doggo choice. Doggo's ratio is not in the database, so the under 10:1 test is not run.
Confirm the servo amplifier delivers both the average and the peak motor current [10]; A multi-cell battery must provide the required capacity and current within the application's voltage limits. [11]Cannot run: no current values.
Doggo runs field-oriented commutation at 10 kHz; treat this as an example, not a limit [6]; Doggo's motor test raised current until the winding reached a steady 125 C, a value often used as the maximum for stator windings. [5]Doggo paper values, as examples.
Protect every power wire with a fuse or breaker located as close as possible to the source bus. [8]Open: no fuse or breaker row on either list.

Sources

Each guideline in this chapter with its source, the date it was read and the exact words of the source. Level: must means breaking it causes failure or harm, should is good practice, guide is a rule of thumb.

  1. Quasi-direct drive uses a single-stage reduction with a ratio under 10:1. It raises torque at the expense of control bandwidth but keeps the motor backdrivable. Level: guide. arxiv.org 2026-11-08
  2. With motor mass scaling with radius, torque scales with radius squared and reflected inertia with radius cubed. Level: guide. arxiv.org 2026-11-08
  3. Expect outrunner motors to trade reduced thermal dissipation and higher inertia for higher torque density. Level: guide. arxiv.org 2026-11-08
  4. Low gear ratios reduce reflected inertia but can increase Joule-heating energy for a given torque. Level: should. fab.cba.mit.edu 2026-11-08
  5. Doggo's motor test raised current until the winding reached a steady 125 C, a value often used as the maximum for stator windings. 125 C Level: guide. arxiv.org 2026-11-08
  6. Doggo runs field-oriented commutation at 10 kHz; treat this as an example, not a limit. 10 kHz Level: guide. arxiv.org 2026-11-08
  7. A servo's stall torque is its maximum momentary output and differs from its continuous rating. Real-world output is generally closer to the performance-graph measurements. Level: guide. emanual.robotis.com 2026-11-08
  8. Protect every power wire with a fuse or breaker located as close as possible to the source bus. Level: must. raanz.org.nz 2026-11-08“with circuit breakers or fuses located as close”
  9. In continuous operation keep motor torque below the thermally set continuous limit, not the peak or stall value. Level: must. hades.mech.northwestern.edu 2026-11-08
  10. Confirm the servo amplifier delivers both the average and the peak motor current. Level: must. maxonmotor.com 2026-11-08
  11. A multi-cell battery must provide the required capacity and current within the application's voltage limits. Level: must. ntrs.nasa.gov 2026-11-08“adequate thermal management. The battery must provide both the capacity and current required”