Design Book › Actuator types

Actuator types

Choose the family from the joint's job, then choose the part from the numbers in chapter 4. Do these in order.

  1. Decide if the joint must be backdrivable or force-controlled. If yes, start at QDD [1]. If precision and torque density matter more, start at harmonic.
  2. Compare rated torque, not peak or stall [2]. A servo's stall torque is its maximum momentary output [3].
  3. Check the kind of each number on the part page. Many low-cost numbers are seller claims.
  4. Fix the exact variant, voltage and revision in the part list, as the voltage and revision guidelines ask [4], [5].

Families

Families
FamilyHow it worksChoose it forMain costs
Serial-bus servoGearmotor, sensor and controller in one case, on a shared serial busMany light joints, per-joint feedback, low priceStall is a momentary figure; backlash; the same name covers many variants
Hobby PWM servoGearmotor taking a pulse for one angleThe cheapest joint, no feedback neededNo position, load or temperature feedback to the host; one signal wire per servo
QDDHigh-torque motor, low-ratio gearbox, FOC driverBackdrivable joints, force control, impactMotor mass per newton-metre; more Joule heat; peak is thermally limited
Planetary-gearedBLDC motor plus steel planetary stage, ratio up to 70:1 in this editionMore torque per motor size, shock toleranceBack-drive torque rises with ratio; gear noise and wear
HarmonicFlexspline and wave generator, a high ratio in one stage, 100:1 at the median in this editionPrecision, torque density, hollow shaftNot backdrivable at high ratio; no public price captured
CycloidalEccentric lobed disc and pinsShock load with small backlashTorque ripple; mass; few off-the-shelf parts
LinearGeared motor and lead screwStraight push or pull, power-off hold below the back-drive forceSlow; limited duty cycle; stalling shortens life

Two more classes appear in the actuator notes. A direct drive joint has low friction, but the motor must be large and heavy. A series elastic actuator gives compliance from a spring and trades bandwidth for it, per the two papers cited.

Spec and price ranges

Each cell is minimum / median / maximum across public fact rows, in SI units. Torque is in N.m. Speed is the listed maximum output speed. Price is USD at quantity 1. A part sold at two voltages can appear once per voltage. These reflect this edition only. "none" means no row in the database, not zero. "not shown" means the rows exist, but this site cannot show them (see chapter 1). Nearly all public actuator values come from the open Dynamic Robot Joint Actuator Comparison data set, which collects maker specs. Open the category for the parts.

Spec and price ranges
FamilyRatio, to oneRated torquePeak torqueMax speed, rpmMass, kgBacklash, arcminPrice, USD
QDD subcategory, all6 / 9 / 400.6 / 9 / 551.8 / 26 / 20052 / 277 / 9000.15 / 0.57 / 2.38 / 10 / 18not shown
Planetary11.4 / 24 / 702 / 30 / 1507 / 110 / 140031 / 123 / 517.80.162 / 0.9 / 3.950.17 / 10 / 15not shown
Harmonic10 / 100 / 1611 / 42 / 3823.3 / 91 / 145810 / 40 / 5000.16 / 1.27 / 9.720.17 / 0.33 / 30none
Cycloidal15 / 30 / 1002 / 45 / 18010 / 128 / 590100 / 130 / 343.80.237 / 1.045 / 3.50.17 / 0.67 / 10none
Direct drive1 / 1 / 10.03 / 0.35 / 2.790.1 / 0.82 / 5.8280 / 1120 / 60000.065 / 0.22 / 0.88nonenone

Servo, DYNAMIXEL actuator and linear actuator rows are left out of this table. This site cannot show nearly any of their values. The STS3215 section below gives the public servo values.

The QDD row is filed by maker line, and it includes ratios up to 40:1. The quasi-direct-drive guideline takes QDD as below 10:1 [1], so a 40:1 part is not QDD. See the split below.

QDD split by ratio

Only parts with a public ratio row are counted. The database holds prices for many of these parts, but this site cannot show them.

QDD split by ratio
GroupRatios on fileRated, N.mPeak, N.mMax speed, rpmMass, kgPrice, USD
Ratio 10:1 or less6, 6.33, 7, 7.75, 7.9, 8, 9, 100.6 / 9.5 / 551.8 / 25 / 20075 / 286.5 / 9000.15 / 0.57 / 2.3not shown
Ratio above 10:136, 39, 408 / 9 / 2424 / 27 / 7252 / 52.5 / 980.362 / 0.556 / 0.75not shown

Parts in the two groups: DM-J4310-2EC V1.1 at 10:1, AK70-9 at 9:1, GO-M8010-6 at 6.33:1, AK45-36 at 36:1, DM-J4340-2EC at 40:1.

Serial-bus servos: the STS3215 data

This is the best-characterised low-cost part in the database. Datasheet and bench values differ, and that is the point of keeping both [6]. For STS3215-C018 at 12 V, the database holds the maker's datasheet values and several bench tests. This book does not show them. The part page links to the maker's page. The public values are in the variant table below.

Three design points follow. Budget backlash from the measured value: a bench test read about 1 deg against a datasheet value of 0.5 deg or less [6]. Log temperature under your worst duty cycle: one test saw issues at 71 C with no apparent built-in protection, and a later page comment says firmware cuts torque near 70 C [7]. Design to the rated value, not the stall figure, which is a momentary maximum [3]. Worked check A in chapter 4 runs this check on an actuator with public values.

The suffix changes the part. A project README rates the 7.4 V version at 16.5 kg.cm stall at 6 V and the 12 V version at 30 kg.cm [4]. Keep one supply per bus segment, as that guideline's check asks. The values in the table below come from that README and from the SO-ARM100 bill of materials.

Serial-bus servos: the STS3215 data
VariantVoltage classRatioStall torquePrice, USD
C0017.4 V345:116.5 kg.cm at 6 V13.89
C01812 Vnot shown30 kg.cm at 12 Vnot shown
C0447.4 V191:1not shown13.89
C0467.4 V147:1not shown13.89

The three 13.89 prices are one Alibaba figure from the SO-ARM100 bill of materials. Other makers sit in the same class at higher prices. The Koch v1.1 bill of materials lists XL330-M288 at $24 each, and a ToddlerBot bill of materials lists XM430-W350 at $310.39 each for the TTL version.

QDD: read the revision and the test

QDD peak values are thermal. Urs et al. list 20 s peak, 2 s peak and continuous torque separately, and note that the Mini Cheetah peak duration was not provided [8]. Use the duration where one exists. None of the rows below states one.

QDD: read the revision and the test
PartRatioRatedPeakMass, kgKind
GO-M8010-66.33:1not listed23.7 Nm0.53spec
RobStride RS-027.75:16 Nm17 Nmnot listedspec
AK70-99:18.5 Nm29.2 Nm0.54spec
RobStride RS-0010:15 Nm14 Nmnot shownspec
DM-J4310-2EC V1.110:13 Nm7 Nm0.3spec

Read the revision as well. CubeMars lists the AK10-9 V2.0 at 48 Nm peak and the V3.0 KV60 at 53 Nm [5].

A QDD gives up control bandwidth and keeps the motor backdrivable [1]. A low ratio reduces reflected inertia but can raise Joule heating for a given torque [9]. For the T-motor U12, an internal single-stage planetary is infeasible above 7:1, and an external one is the better option from 7:1 to 11:1 [10].

Harmonic and cycloidal

The MyActuator EPS-RH-17 at 100:1 lists 35 Nm rated and 54 Nm peak, at 30 rpm maximum. High ratio costs speed: the 50:1 version of the same frame lists 17.5 Nm rated at 60 rpm. The same gear limits apply as in chapter 6. Do not rely on backdriving torque to hold a load; fit a brake [11].

Among the cycloidal actuators, the Leadshine HRV2-90FXD19 at 31:1 lists 50 Nm rated and 120 Nm peak, with 40 arcsec backlash, at 1.65 kg. No cycloidal actuator in the database has a price row. The gearbox category lists commercial cycloidal gearboxes, such as Nabtesco RV-6E and Sumitomo Fine Cyclo FC-A, with no price row.

Linear

Actuonix sells the P16 at several ratios, such as P16 22:1, 64:1 and 256:1. A higher ratio gives more force at a lower speed. The database holds force, speed and backlash for each, but this site does not show them. The screw guidelines in chapter 6 apply [12]. Firgelli linear actuators, such as the tubular model, have no fact rows in this edition.

Drivers

A bus servo holds its own driver. A QDD module usually does too. A bare motor needs a motor driver. A FOC servo driver gives direct torque control through a current loop; examples are moteus r4.11 and ODrive S1. FOC controllers with a public price run $69 / $94 / $175 at quantity 1 in this edition. Confirm the driver covers average and peak current [13].

Sources

Each guideline in this chapter with its source, the date it was read and the exact words of the source. Level: must means breaking it causes failure or harm, should is good practice, guide is a rule of thumb.

  1. Quasi-direct drive uses a single-stage reduction with a ratio under 10:1. It raises torque at the expense of control bandwidth but keeps the motor backdrivable. Level: guide. arxiv.org 2026-11-08
  2. In continuous operation keep motor torque below the thermally set continuous limit, not the peak or stall value. Level: must. hades.mech.northwestern.edu 2026-11-08
  3. A servo's stall torque is its maximum momentary output and differs from its continuous rating. Real-world output is generally closer to the performance-graph measurements. Level: guide. emanual.robotis.com 2026-11-08
  4. The STS3215 7.4 V version is rated at 16.5 kg·cm stall torque at 6 V; the 12 V version is rated at 30 kg·cm. Level: guide. github.com 2026-11-08“The 12V version has a stall torque of 30kg.cm.”
  5. CubeMars lists the AK10-9 V2.0 at 48 Nm peak and the AK10-9 V3.0 KV60 at 53 Nm peak. Level: guide. cubemars.com 2026-11-08
  6. A bench test of the STS3215 measured about 1° of encoder backlash against a ≤0.5° datasheet value. Level: guide. github.com 2026-11-08
  7. In a Robonine STS3215 test, issues appeared at 71°C and no built-in thermal protection was apparent, so manual shutdown is needed at that temperature. A later page comment says firmware protection cuts torque near 70°C. Level: should. robonine.com 2026-11-08
  8. Urs et al. (3D-printed actuators) list 20 s peak, 2 s peak and continuous torque separately and note the Mini Cheetah peak duration was not provided. Level: guide. arxiv.org 2026-11-08
  9. Low gear ratios reduce reflected inertia but can increase Joule-heating energy for a given torque. Level: should. fab.cba.mit.edu 2026-11-08
  10. For the T-motor U12, an internal single-stage planetary gearbox is infeasible above 7:1, and an external one is the better option from 7:1 to 11:1. 7 Level: guide. arxiv.org 2026-11-08“7:1, ISSPG becomes infeasible, making ESSPG the better option ratios, and spring stiffness while overlooking gearbox design. in the 7:1 to 11:1 range.”
  11. Do not rely on backdriving torque to hold load; fit a failsafe brake. Level: should. harmonicdrive.net 2026-11-08
  12. A screw is not backdrivable when its lead is below the critical value pi mu D / cos(alpha). Level: should. pergatory.mit.edu 2026-11-08
  13. Confirm the servo amplifier delivers both the average and the peak motor current. Level: must. maxonmotor.com 2026-11-08