Design Book › Choosing a robot type

Choosing a robot type

Do this before you choose any part.

  1. Write the task: what is carried, how far, over what ground, and whether a person is near.
  2. Choose the class whose limits you can accept. Each class below states its costs.
  3. Find a catalogued robot close to your numbers. If nothing is close, ask why before you design one.
  4. Read its joint count against the degrees-of-freedom guideline [1]: under six degrees of freedom, the tool cannot move in every spatial direction.

Classes at a glance

Classes come from the catalog. Browse the models on Robots.

Classes at a glance
GroupClassLayoutChoose it whenMain costExample
ArmSerial articulatedChain of rigid links and motor-driven jointsYou need wide reach and tool orientation from one baseJoint errors add along the chain; singularities near some posesUR12e
ArmCobotLight arm with limits on force and speedIt works near people, after a risk assessmentSpeed and force limits cut throughput; safety rests on the whole cellFR3
ArmDesktop leader-followerHobby servo arms for teleoperation dataYou collect imitation-learning data on a budgetLow-cost servos limit accuracy and torque; build quality variesSO-ARM101
ArmDual-armTwo arms on one frameThe task needs two handsDoubles cost, calibration and collision checksALOHA
ArmSCARATwo parallel vertical rotary joints plus a vertical slideFlat assembly, pin insertion, pick and placeNo tool tiltMG400
ArmCartesian or gantryThree linear axes at right anglesStraight-line moves over a large volumeLarge frame for the reach; no tool orientation without a wristnone in Robots
ArmDeltaThree arms to a small platform, motors in the baseVery fast picking of light partsSmall working volumenone in Robots
ArmParallel (Stewart)Several short chains to one platformStiff, accurate positioningLimited workspace; singularities inside itnone in Robots
LeggedHumanoidTorso, head, two arms, two legsThe space and tools are made for peopleBalance, falls, short runtime, costG1
LeggedQuadrupedFour walking legsStairs and rough ground, carrying sensorsMechanical complexity; slow on flat floorsGo2
MobileWheeled or tracked baseDifferential, omnidirectional or trackedFlat floors, lowest energy per metreNo stairs or gapsSCOUT MINI
MobileMobile manipulatorArm on a mobile platformA small arm must serve a large areaBase and arm motion couple; tip-over limits payloadStretch 4
End-effectorGripperJaws, suction, magnets, adhesiveKnown parts, fast cycleLimited part range; little in-hand motionHand-E
End-effectorDexterous handMulti-finger hand, tendon or direct driveIn-hand manipulation, human toolsHeavy; many failure points; calibration workShadow Hand
AerialUnmanned aerial vehicleMultirotor, fixed wing, rotorcraftFast access over any terrainShort flight time; little payload; airspace rulesSkydio X2
WearableExoskeletonRigid, soft or passive, worn on the bodyAssist an existing body partFit and safety; battery mass; medical regulationEkso EVO

Arms

Values are maker specs unless marked. A value marked (claim) is a maker or project claim, and (measured) is the maker's own measured result. The Universal Robots rows come from the model table in the Wikipedia article on the maker. Prices are single-unit rows from the robot page.

Arms
ModelClassJointsPayloadReachMassRepeatabilityPrice
SO-ARM101 pairDesktopnot listed150 g (claim)441 mm (claim)not listednot listednot shown
SO-ARM102Desktop5 (claim)300 g (claim)483 mm (claim)not listed0.1 mm (measured)not listed
Koch v1.1Desktopnot listednot listednot listednot listednot listed$278 parts for one follower
WidowX AIDesktop61.5 kg769 mm4 kgnot shownnot shown
PAROL6Serial6 (claim)0.5 to 1 kg (claim)408 mm (claim)5.5 kg (claim)0.1 mm (claim)not listed
Z1Serialnot listed2 to 3 kg740 mm4.3 to 4.5 kg0.1 mmnot shown
FR3Research cobot73 kg855 mmnot listed0.1 mmnot listed
UR3eCobotnot listed3 kg500 mm11.2 kgnot shownnot listed
UR5eCobotnot shown5 kg850 mm20.6 kgnot shownnot listed
UR10eCobotnot shown12.5 kg1300 mm33.5 kgnot shownnot listed
UR16eCobotnot shown16 kg900 mm33.1 kgnot shownnot listed
UR20Cobotnot listed20 kg1750 mm64 kgnot listednot listed
UR30Cobotnot listed30 kg1300 mm64 kgnot listednot listed

Read these rows as trade-offs. UR20 and UR30 both weigh 64 kg: one gives 1750 mm reach at 20 kg, the other 1300 mm at 30 kg. UR10e and UR16e both weigh about 33 kg: one gives 1300 mm at 12.5 kg, the other 900 mm at 16 kg. Payload falls as reach grows. Low-cost arms seldom state repeatability, and the figures that exist differ in kind. SO-ARM102 gives 0.1 mm from the maker's own measurement, PAROL6 claims 0.1 mm, and FR3 states 0.1 mm as a spec. The same number can rest on very different tests. Quote repeatability with its test method, as the guideline on accuracy figures asks [2]. That guideline gives ISO 9283:1998 by its title only. The standard sets how to state and test the accuracy and repeatability of an industrial robot.

A seventh axis lets the elbow move without moving the tool, as on FR3. It makes the chain redundant, so plan inverse kinematics for it [3].

The robot table holds no gantry, delta or Stewart model in this edition. Those classes rest on class notes only. Size them from the guidelines in chapters 3 and 4.

Legged robots

Values marked (c) are claims from the Wikipedia article on Valkyrie. Others are maker specs.

Legged robots
ModelClassJointsHeightMassPayloadRuntimePrice
ValkyrieHumanoid44 (c)1.87 m (c)129 kg (c)not listedabout 1 hour (c)not listed
H2Humanoid311820 mm70 kgnot listednot listed$29,900
G1Humanoid231320 mm35 kgabout 2 kg per armnot listedfrom $13,500
R1Humanoid261230 mm29 kgnot listednot listed$5,900
TALOSHumanoidnot listed175 cm95 kg6 kg per arm1.5 h walkingnot listed
Go2Quadrupednot listednot listed15 kgabout 7 kgnot listedfrom $1,600
As2Quadruped12not listed20 kg65 kg standing, 15 kg walking4 h unloaded, 2.5 h loadednot shown
B2Quadrupednot listednot listed60 kg120 kg standing, 40 kg walking4 to 6 hnot shown
A2Quadruped12not listed42 kgnot listednot listednot shown

Do not compare payload numbers across rows without reading the condition. B2 lists 120 kg standing but 40 kg walking. As2 lists 65 kg standing but 15 kg walking. Only the walking figure says what the robot carries as it moves. A load also costs runtime: As2 lists 4 h unloaded and 2.5 h loaded. The H1 has no price this site can show. Ask the maker.

A quasi-direct drive, a single stage under 10:1, keeps the motor backdrivable [4]. A low ratio can raise Joule heating for a given torque [5]. Size the joints from chapter 4, and read QDD actuators next.

Mobile robots

Mobile robots
ModelClassPayloadMassRuntimeOtherPrice
TIAGo ProMobile manipulator3 kg per armnot listednot listedTwo 7-DoF arms, vertical reach 92 cmnot listed
TIAGoMobile manipulator3 kgnot listed4-5h, or 8-10h with 2 batteriesHeight 110-145 cmnot listed
LeKiwiMobile manipulatornot listednot listednot listedSelf-sourced parts, 12 V version$482
XLeRobotMobile manipulator600 to 1000 g per arm (claim)12 kg (claim)8 to 12 hours (claim)Self-sourced parts, basic versionabout $660
Open Source RoverWheeled rovernot listednot listedat least 3 hours on rough terrain (claim)7.2 Ah battery (claim)not listed

The battery serves both drive and arm on a mobile manipulator. Size it for both (chapter 10, [6]).

End-effectors

The gripper and hand category pages describe each class. All values are maker specs unless marked (claim). The Shadow row comes from the Wikipedia article on the hand.

End-effectors
GripperClassStrokeGrip forcePayloadMassClosing time
Dex1-1Parallel electric90 mm5 to 120 N20 kg, form-fitting grasp550 g0.24 s
Robotiq Hand-EParallel electric50 or 100 mmnot listed7 kg, silicone-covered fingertipsnot listednot listed

Read the payload condition. The class note says payload is quoted for friction grip, not form fit. Dex1-1 lists its 20 kg for a form-fitting grasp, and Robotiq Hand-E lists its 7 kg for silicone-covered fingertips. A linkage gripper wraps round parts but gives up position accuracy. A rotary gripper saves a separate joint, at the cost of a short stroke.

End-effectors
HandClassJoints or DoFMassPayloadPrice or build cost
Shadow Dexterous HandTendon driven20 motors, 24 joints (claim)not shownnot listednot listed
ORCA v2.1 baseTendon driven17 DoFnot listednot listed$3,500
Dex3-1Direct drive7 joints710 g500 gnot shown
Dex5-SDirect drive22 DoF620 g1 kgnot shown

Tendon hands keep the fingers light, at the cost of tendon wear and less certain joint angles. In-finger actuators read joint state directly, and carry mass at the fingers. Hand mass sits at the end of the arm. Count it in the joint budget [7].

Aerial and wearable

The catalog holds aerial models such as Skydio X2, Crazyflie 2 and Ingenuity. The database gives Crazyflie 2.0 27 g, 7 minutes and 15 g payload, and Ingenuity 1.8 kg and 90 s. It also holds a mass and a flight time for Skydio X2, but they are not shown, because their source does not allow copying. The database has no thrust number for any of the three.

The robot table holds one exoskeleton, Ekso EVO. Its mass, assistance force and spring life are not shown, because their source does not allow copying. The class notes name the variations and the costs. One product gives no range to size a design with.

Sources

Each guideline in this chapter with its source, the date it was read and the exact words of the source. Level: must means breaking it causes failure or harm, should is good practice, guide is a rule of thumb.

  1. A manipulator with under six degrees of freedom cannot move in every spatial direction; a singular configuration lowers its end-effector freedom further. Level: should. cds.caltech.edu 2026-11-08
  2. This guideline is held back: its source does not allow us to publish it yet.
  3. Call a chain redundant only if it has more joints than task space dimensions, and plan inverse kinematics with the pseudoinverse. Level: should. hades.mech.northwestern.edu 2026-11-08
  4. Quasi-direct drive uses a single-stage reduction with a ratio under 10:1. It raises torque at the expense of control bandwidth but keeps the motor backdrivable. Level: guide. arxiv.org 2026-11-08
  5. Low gear ratios reduce reflected inertia but can increase Joule-heating energy for a given torque. Level: should. fab.cba.mit.edu 2026-11-08
  6. A multi-cell battery must provide the required capacity and current within the application's voltage limits. Level: must. ntrs.nasa.gov 2026-11-08“adequate thermal management. The battery must provide both the capacity and current required”
  7. Include gravity in the joint torque budget from the equations of motion, tau = M ddq + c + g. Level: should. hades.mech.northwestern.edu 2026-11-08